Trump’s impeachment could be the liberation of the Republican Party


COOPER, Iowa, Dec. 30, 2019 – We were talking politics in the living room of our west central Iowa farmhouse here the other day with our longtime pal Mary Riche, who is a very active Democrat in the Des Moines area.

“We are living in very historic times,” Riche said.

Indeed we are.

Her observation gave me an opening to share my own vision of what we’ve recently been through, especially in this fading year of 2019, and what I see coming in the very promising year of 2020.

For those just tuning in, I need to explain that I come from across the political spectrum – all across it. I’m now a registered Democrat for what I believe is the fifth time in my adulthood. I’ve been a Republican through three political cycles, a No Party voter twice, and a Libertarian once

Impeachment graphic from CNN.jpg

A graphic from CNN.

Here, in brief, is where I see us right now:

–The presidency of Donald J. Trump is essentially over.

–We’ll forever be talking about his impeachment, which the U.S. House of Representatives approved on Dec. 18 on charges that Trump abused his presidential powers and obstructed the lawful proceedings of Congress. But something else began as those contentious proceedings were concluding in the House – the liberation of the Republican Party. The tip-off on that was how, almost suddenly, we saw potential Republican leaders like Nikki Haley, the former South Carolina governor & U.S. ambassador to the United Nations; Senator Ted Cruz, of Texas, and Senator Marco Rubio, of Florida, elevating their public profiles.

–The impeachment effort, at some point, is expected to move into the U.S. Senate for the formal trial. It’s not likely that the Republican-dominated Senate will convict the president and remove him from office. But I see a deal being cut within the GOP. A coalition of party leaders, now rediscovering their backbones, will seize the opportunity to get rid of Trump. They will go to him with three options: 1) He can resign now. 2) He can be cooperative as the Senate trial happens, remain in office until his term ends, but announce soon that he will not seek re-election. 3) If necessary, some Republican senators with strong character and consciences, will tell him that if he does not agree to leave the presidency as proposed in options 1 or 2, they will scald him during the Senate trial, raising the possibility he might be convicted and removed from office, and they’ll encourage a new generation of Republicans to challenge him in the 2020 campaign.

–There is always the possibility that the badly-tempered Trump, at any moment, could get mad, quit and flee to his fantasyland home Mar-a-Lago.

–Of course, all of the above will blow-up the current race for the presidency, for both Republicans and Democrats. Think of it as the ultimate exorcism of us Baby Boomers from public life. That’s my generation, and I say we’ve earned such an ouster by refusing to leave the stage. What we’ve all witnessed lately is not only the impeachment of Donald Trump, but also the impeachment of the idea that anybody over 70 years old should be serving as our president.

If there is a political rapture like I’m describing, then any candidates who earlier got in the race, then decided to get out, might well decide to get back in again. The whole race could re-boot

Who will emerge as the parties’ nominees?

For the Democrats, I see one of the moderates becoming the presidential nominee – Mayor Pete Buttigieg of South Bend, Ind.; or Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota; or, as a longshot, Montana Governor Steve Bullock, one of those in the race earlier, and, yes, I think former Congressman John Delaney, of Maryland, the candidate I endorsed in September, still has a chance. Delaney, the once-in-a-lifetime Democrat who has been successful both in business and politics, has worked harder than all other candidates in Iowa. He wants to work bi-partisanly to unite the nation, creatively address big issues like climate change, and rebuild our international relations and trade. In a less-rancorous “Campaign 2.0” – if that’s what we’d want to call it – people will re-discover Delaney.

For the Republicans, I think Vice-President Mike Pence, the former governor of Indiana, will go down with Trump. Nikki Haley seems to me to be best positioned as the GOP nominee, but don’t underestimate Ted Cruz – remember, he beat Trump in the Iowa Caucuses in 2016. And a lot of younger Iowa Republicans back then liked Rubio, too.

Note that the oldest person I’ve mentioned among my contenders here is Klobuchar, at 59. Delaney is 56, Bullock is 53, Buttigieg is 37. Among the Republicans I’m watching, Cruz is 49, Marco Rubio is 48, and Haley is 47.

One thing I’m confident of is that, with the next generation in charge, politics in both parties will be better, more visionary and more effective.

Yes, it was quite a conversation there in our living room. Carla Offenburger, who has heard all it before, was rolling her eyes. Our friend Mary Riche seemed startled. The few other people I’ve shared this vision with have generally been startled by it, too.

Stranger things have happened, I then tell them.

Like what?

Donald Trump, that’s what.

You can email the columnist at or comment using the handy form below here.

5 thoughts on “Trump’s impeachment could be the liberation of the Republican Party

  1. Great analysis! I, too, am tired of old white men (as I look in the mirror?). But wish I could share your optimism. Trump is too bull-headed to go willingly. And Republican backbones? Pretty scarce! We’ve met and chatted with Bullock, and really liked him. That would be great if he came back on the scene. Klobuchar and Mayor Pete say the right things, too. Can’t wait for the next generation. Hope this country survives until they’re in control!

    Larry Stone, Elkader IA

  2. Beyond Mitt Romney name a single Republican who thinks Trump’s slurs, insults and boorish behavior is objectionable. The Republicans have no principles whatsoever. If you are a Republican reading this, please name those principles. Really, I am not optimistic. The lowest common slur is the word of the day. Very sad. No such thing as a decent discussion of national needs and interests. Look to more Trump and the loss of our republic.

    Art Seaman, Kittanning PA

  3. I couldn’t agree more, Chuck. For the past year-plus, I have been sharing that I want to vote for someone under the age of 50, which is younger than me! I agree this generation of politicians has hung on too long. We are 20 years into the 21st century, time to step aside! I feel it is time to have leaders that DON’T remember a time without a microwave oven or color TV. The future is here! I pray that our nation can heal.

    Karin Lawton-Dunn, Grimes IA

  4. I think it hinges on whether or not the Senate allows/insists on hearing from Bolton and/or Mulvaney or others! If either one or more talk, I think it will be the end of the Trump presidency. Then Chuck’s thoughts take over!

    Lowell Norland, Cincinnati, OH

  5. Actually, Chuck, I see President Trump as uniting the Republicans and equipping them with a backbone. For years Democrats have repeated lies and Republicans have played defense. (Recent example: Cartier Page spying for Russia when in reality he was spying for the CIA.) Remember Harry Reid accusing Mitt Romney of not paying his taxes? Then saying after the election “It worked — we won” [paraphrased]. It appears you didn’t watch Jim Jordan, among others, during the Schiff “hearings.” He is definitely a rising star with no holds barred. As for Nikki Haley going to President Trump asking him to resign, I heard her talking about her experience when working with him — sure didn’t sound anything like what we hear on the main stream media. My conclusion is she really likes him and felt respected by him. I guess I’m a little disappointed that you have become so emersed in being a Democrat that you can’t see beyond the party line.

    Joan Conroy, Jefferson IA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *